Major League Baseball (MLB) has added a second wildcard team from each league. It is the first playoff expansion since 1995. Adding more cities with an opportunity to make the postseason is the right thing to do. Baseball still trails every other sport in the percentage of teams that qualify for the playoffs, despite playing twice as many games. However, I have mixed feelings about this. I like that another team will have a chance to make the playoffs. I don’t like that the two wildcard team will play a one game play-in. The winner of the one-game playoff will face the team with the league’s best record in the Division Series.
My biggest objection of the new playoff system is that after undergoing an arduous 162-game season and earning a playoff berth, two teams can be eliminated in 24 hours.
If the playoffs had included 10 teams when the wildcard was implemented in 1995, the second wildcard team would have averaged 89 victories. And 11 teams would have won at least 90 games, so by adding the second wildcard team they aren’t diluting the quality of teams making the playoffs. The 2011 St. Louis Cardinals are the fifth wildcard team to win the World Series since the playoff field doubled in 1995. The other four wildcard champions were the Florida Marlins (now the Miami Marlins) in 1997 and 2003, the Anaheim Angels (now the Los Angeles Angels of Anaheim) in 2002 and the Boston Red Sox in 2004.
Follow the Money
This is obviously all about the money. By having what amounts to a Game 7 in each league MLB will draw a huge audience. This should recreate the same type of excitement that was played out on September 28, 2011. Arguably, this was the best night ever in MLB history. Ironically had this system been implemented last year despite their staggering September collapses, the Red Sox and Atlanta Braves would have gotten into the playoffs as the second wildcard under the new system.
The most significant impact this change has is that now winning your division is even more important. Not only do you get home field advantage, but you won’t have to play in that one-game playoff. Even if you win the “play-in” game you have probably used your ace pitcher. Plus, it’s another day they have to use their bullpen. So even if you get by that one game, the chances of winning the next round are not very good.
A Third Place Team Could Win the World Series
Here is the ugly scenario that could happen under the new system. Let’s say Team A wins 95 games but finishes second to Team B and then gets eliminated in the one-game playoff by Team C that won only 86 games. In this scenario, a third place team could win the World Series.
There will always be inequity when leagues are divided into divisions. This allows for the possibility of a team missing the playoffs with a better record than some of those that qualified. Bottom line, win your division.
The American League East could have three strong teams fighting for the division title. The New York Yankees, Tampa Bay Rays and Red Sox want to get into the postseason, but not as a wildcard with the chance of being eliminated in one game. As long as a team still has chance to win the division there won’t be any resting of starters, even if they have clinched a wildcard spot.
On the flip side, once a team has locked up the American League Central they will have the luxury of resting their starters because no other team in their division is contending for either the division or one of the two wild cards. In this scenario the new format hurts the teams in strong divisions while rewarding teams in weak divisions that it can clinch early.
It’s Not Fair!
As long as you have divisions and wildcards there will be unfairness. Before 1969, the two teams with the best record in their respective leagues played the World Championship and home field advantage wasn’t determined by a meaningless exhibition game. MLB split into two divisions in each league in 1969, and in 1994 they went to three divisions. 1995 was the year the wild card came into existence.
The primary reason the wildcard was added was related to the 1993 season. The San Francisco Giants finished the season with a 103-59, but didn’t make the playoffs because they were unfortunately in the same division as the 104-58 Atlanta Braves. Adding wildcards doesn’t resolve the problem because it’s possible the wild card team(s) has a better record than two other division winners, yet they have to take part in the play-in game.
To prove my point, since 1995, 14 teams have missed the playoffs even though they had a better record than one of the division winners. Doesn’t seem right, does it?
A Better Idea
If I were “King” I have the five teams with the best records in each league (regardless of Divisions) and have the two lowest teams play a best of two out of three to determine the fourth team. Teams shouldn’t be rewarded because they play in a weak division. If you’re barely over .500, you shouldn’t make the playoffs.




























.GrandSlamSports360.com
Baseball Memorabilia and Collectibles
Display Cases for Collectibles
Sports Tailgating